As someone who has spent years analyzing financial instruments, I find Permanent Interest Bearing Shares (PIBS) to be a fascinating yet often overlooked investment option. If you’re new to fixed-income securities or exploring alternatives to traditional bonds, this guide will help you understand PIBS in depth. I’ll explain how they work, their advantages, risks, and how they compare to other debt instruments—all while keeping the discussion grounded in practical examples.
Table of Contents
What Are Permanent Interest Bearing Shares?
Permanent Interest Bearing Shares (PIBS) are a type of perpetual debt instrument issued primarily by UK building societies, though similar structures exist in other markets. Unlike bonds, PIBS have no maturity date, meaning the issuer has no obligation to repay the principal. Instead, investors receive fixed interest payments indefinitely, making them a hybrid between debt and equity.
Key Features of PIBS
- No Maturity Date: PIBS are perpetual, meaning they don’t expire.
- Fixed Interest Rate: The coupon rate remains constant unless the issuer defaults.
- Subordinated Debt: They rank below other creditors in case of liquidation.
- Traded on Stock Exchanges: Unlike traditional bonds, PIBS are often listed and traded like shares.
How Do PIBS Work?
When I first encountered PIBS, I was struck by their resemblance to preferred stock in the U.S. market. However, PIBS are legally debt instruments, not equity. Here’s a breakdown of their mechanics:
Interest Payments
PIBS pay a fixed interest rate, usually semi-annually or annually. For example, if you hold £10,000 in PIBS with a 5% coupon, you receive:
Interest = Principal \times Coupon Rate = £10,000 \times 0.05 = £500 \text{ per year}Unlike bonds, this payment continues forever unless the issuer redeems the shares (which is rare).
No Principal Repayment
Since PIBS are perpetual, the issuer never has to return your initial investment. This makes them riskier than conventional bonds but also means they often offer higher yields to compensate.
Trading PIBS
PIBS trade on stock exchanges, meaning their prices fluctuate based on:
- Interest rate changes (higher rates depress PIBS prices).
- Issuer’s creditworthiness (a downgrade lowers demand).
- Market liquidity (PIBS are less liquid than government bonds).
PIBS vs. Other Fixed-Income Instruments
To understand where PIBS fit in, let’s compare them to bonds, preferred stock, and perpetual bonds:
| Feature | PIBS | Corporate Bonds | Preferred Stock | Perpetual Bonds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maturity | None | Fixed term | None | None |
| Interest Type | Fixed | Fixed/Variable | Fixed/Dividend | Fixed/Variable |
| Seniority | Subordinated | Senior/Unsecured | Equity-like | Varies |
| Trading Venue | Stock Exchange | OTC/Exchange | Stock Exchange | OTC/Exchange |
| Tax Treatment | Interest Income | Interest Income | Dividend Income | Interest Income |
Why Choose PIBS Over Bonds?
- Higher Yield: Since PIBS are riskier, they often pay more than equivalent bonds.
- Perpetual Income: If you seek long-term cash flow, PIBS provide indefinite payments.
- Diversification: They add a different risk-return profile to a fixed-income portfolio.
Risks of Investing in PIBS
While PIBS offer attractive yields, they come with unique risks:
1. Interest Rate Risk
Since PIBS have no maturity, their prices are highly sensitive to interest rate changes. The relationship follows the perpetuity formula:
Price = \frac{Annual\ Payment}{Discount\ Rate}For example, if a PIBS pays £500 annually and market rates rise from 5% to 6%, its price drops:
Price_{5\%} = \frac{500}{0.05} = £10,000 Price_{6\%} = \frac{500}{0.06} = £8,333A 1% rate hike causes a 16.7% price decline—much steeper than a typical bond.
2. Credit Risk
PIBS are subordinated, meaning if the issuer goes bankrupt, you’re paid after senior creditors. Some UK building societies have failed, leaving PIBS holders with heavy losses.
3. Liquidity Risk
PIBS trade less frequently than government bonds, so selling large holdings quickly may require accepting a lower price.
Tax Implications of PIBS
In the U.S., PIBS are treated as debt instruments, so interest is taxable as ordinary income. Unlike dividends, they don’t qualify for the lower qualified dividend tax rate.
Real-World Example: Investing in PIBS
Suppose you buy £20,000 of PIBS issued by a UK building society with a 6% coupon. Here’s how it plays out:
- Annual Income: £20,000 \times 0.06 = £1,200
- If Interest Rates Rise to 7%:
New\ Price = \frac{1,200}{0.07} = £17,143 (a 14.3% capital loss) - If the Issuer’s Credit Rating Drops: The market may demand a higher yield, further depressing the price.
Should You Invest in PIBS?
PIBS suit investors who:
- Seek high, stable income and don’t need principal returned.
- Understand interest rate risks and can tolerate price volatility.
- Diversify beyond traditional bonds and stocks.
However, they’re not ideal for those needing capital preservation or low-risk investments.
Final Thoughts
Permanent Interest Bearing Shares occupy a niche but valuable space in fixed-income investing. Their perpetual nature and higher yields make them appealing, but the risks—especially from rising rates—require careful consideration. If you’re comfortable with these trade-offs, PIBS can be a compelling addition to a diversified portfolio.
