I need to clear up a point of confusion I encounter almost every week. A client will sit across from me and ask for a safe mutual fund. They want one with a guaranteed return. They have heard about something called an “assured return scheme.” They want security. They want predictability. I understand this desire completely. The problem is this: the term “assured return scheme mutual fund” is largely a myth. In the United States, a traditional mutual fund cannot legally promise you a specific return. The search for one leads investors into dangerous territory, often toward products that are not what they seem. Let’s break down why this is the case and what your actual options are.
Table of Contents
The Iron Rule: Mutual Funds Are Not FDIC-Insured
This is the most critical point to internalize. When you buy a mutual fund, you are buying a security. You are not making a deposit into a bank.
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) guarantees bank deposits up to \$250,000 per depositor, per insured bank. This is a government-backed promise. Your money is safe from loss.
Mutual funds carry no such guarantee. Every mutual fund prospectus must include a standard disclaimer: “Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.” It must also state: “You could lose money by investing in the fund.” This is not legalese. This is a fundamental truth. A mutual fund company cannot assure you of a return because the value of the underlying stocks and bonds it holds fluctuates with the market.
What People Mistake for “Assured Return” Schemes
So why does this idea persist? Investors often mislabel certain types of lower-risk funds as “assured.”
1. Money Market Funds: These are the closest thing to a cash-equivalent investment in the mutual fund universe. They invest in high-quality, short-term debt. They aim to maintain a stable net asset value (NAV) of \$1 per share. However, they are not guaranteed. There have been rare instances, known as “breaking the buck,” where a money market fund’s NAV fell below \$1. While extremely low risk, they are not risk-free and their yields fluctuate.
2. Stable Value Funds: Often found in 401(k) plans, these funds invest in insured bonds and use insurance contracts to smooth returns. They aim for capital preservation and steady, modest income. They are less volatile than bond funds, but they are still not a guaranteed return. The return is not fixed; it can change, and the insurance is only as good as the company providing it.
3. Principal-Protected Notes (PPNs): These are structured products, not mutual funds. A PPN might promise to return your initial investment at maturity while offering participation in market gains. They are complex, often illiquid, and the “protection” is only as solid as the financial institution issuing it (typically a bank). They carry counterparty risk.
The Dangerous Imposters: What to Avoid
The desire for a guaranteed outcome can make investors vulnerable to products that use misleading language.
- Annuities Masquerading as Funds: A variable annuity with a guaranteed living benefit rider might be pitched as a way to “participate in the market upside with downside protection.” This is not a mutual fund. It is an insurance contract with high fees, surrender charges, and complex rules. The guarantee is also contingent on the solvency of the insurance company.
- Bond Funds with High Yields: A fund offering a yield that seems too good to be true, like 8% or 9%, is often taking on significant credit risk or interest rate risk. The high yield is not assured; it is a target that can evaporate if the fund’s holdings default or lose value.
The Math of Risk and Return
The fundamental law of investing is the risk-return tradeoff. To expect a higher potential return, you must accept a higher level of risk. A promise of an “assured” high return is a mathematical impossibility in a free market.
Let’s say a product promises a 5% assured return. For the issuer to generate that return risk-free, they would need to invest in U.S. Treasury securities. But the 10-year Treasury note might only be yielding 4%. Where does the extra 1% come from? It must come from taking risk, or from your own money in the form of high fees. The numbers must add up. A promise that seems too good to be true is built on a foundation of risk or obscurity.
Your Realistic Path to Lower Risk
If you cannot have an assured return, what can you do? Your goal should be to build a portfolio that aligns with your risk tolerance.
- Define Your Goals: Is this money for a down payment in two years or for retirement in thirty years? Short-term goals should use conservative assets like money market funds or short-term bond funds, accepting that returns will be low but stable.
- Understand Asset Allocation: This is the most important decision you will make. A portfolio of 80% stocks and 20% bonds has a different risk profile than one that is 20% stocks and 80% bonds. The latter will be far less volatile, though it will not offer assured returns.
- Consider Series I Savings Bonds: For a truly guaranteed outcome, look to U.S. government savings bonds. Series I bonds are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. Their interest rate combines a fixed rate and an inflation rate. They protect your principal and keep pace with inflation. They are not mutual funds, but they are one of the safest investments available.
- Work with a Fiduciary: A financial advisor who is a fiduciary is legally obligated to act in your best interest. They can help you construct a suitable portfolio without pushing high-commission products that promise the moon.
My Final Perspective
Chasing an “assured return scheme mutual fund” is a quest for a financial unicorn. It does not exist in the form most people imagine. The search for this myth can lead you to make poor decisions, often into expensive, complex, or risky products that are dressed up as safe.
True investing is not about finding guarantees. It is about understanding and managing risk. It is about diversification. It is about matching your investments to your time horizon and emotional capacity for market swings. Embrace this reality. Build a solid, transparent portfolio of low-cost funds. This is a far more powerful strategy than chasing a promised return that, upon closer inspection, was never really there.
